The Real Purpose of News
So there I was minding other peoples business on Twitter when somebody made a comment about Balloon Boy. I had no idea what they were talking about and foolishly said so.
I was then deluged with links to the story about some kid who hadn’t climbed into his fathers hot air balloon, and then hadn’t floated half way across Colorado to his certain death.
Apparently some people thought he was in the balloon, hence half the country was on tenterhooks and the other half out scouring the countryside looking for shiny silver fabric and bits of boy
That was worth 10 minutes out of my life. Or maybe not.
I hardly ever watch or listen to the news. Actually that’s not technically true, sometimes when I’m out in my car and the NFL channel on Sirius goes to a commercial break I’ll flick over to the BBC World Service for a couple of minutes and will occasionally catch a snippet of a news program.
It’s not that I have ADHD and need to be seeking constant stimulation. It’s more that if I have haven’t changed over by the end of the advertisements I’m usually looking for the nearest tree to stop by and hurl a rope over.
I’m not quite sure how the advertisers get away with the fear they spread wrapped up in lies and half truths, because some are so outrageous as to be almost comical, but get away with it they do.
Here is the opening line of one advert that is running almost continuously on Sirius at the moment:
“In this stressful economy, smokers are smoking more and being taxed more”
Every time I hear it I want to scream “What the hell do you mean by a stressful economy? That makes absolutely no linguistic sense, an economy cannot be stressed, and I wasn’t stressed living in this one until I started listening to you!
How do they know smokers are smoking more? Have they done an in-depth study? I doubt it, it’s pure hyperbole.
Another advert asks:
“Do you drive a car with less than 200,000 miles on the clock and is it out of warranty?”
Well I’m no expert, but I’m guessing that’s about half the population. It’s a classic ploy by advertisers to make you think they are talking to you specifically.
On hearing the two questions most people will respond to the positive and prick up their ears thinking “I’d better listen because this applies to me”
Then the guy with the stern voice reels off how many things will probably drop off your car in the next 5 minutes if you don’t send him all your money. Not only that, but he kindly points out that car manufacturers are struggling and will probably want to charge you more for the parts to recoup their losses.
Then in a brilliant twist to grab the attention of Mr Smug in his brand new warranty covered Chevy, the advert points out that even if you do have a warranty, what happens when the car companies go bankrupt, who’ll pay for your repairs then eh?
In my opinion, news and adverts are very similar because both are very carefully crafted to scare people. Yet whereas people are happy to admit the follow the news closely, few outside of Superbowl Sunday will admit to studiously watching adverts.
It seems everybody knows advertisers lie, misrepresent and con, even though some ads are very clever and even hilarious on occasions. So many people including this life coach record programs on DVR or ‘time slip’ them and then skim past all the adverts.
Yet it never occurs to many people to skim past the news.
Why do you think that is?
Do you think we’ve maybe been sold a lie to the real value of news?
Personally, I think it adds more or less zero value to my life. When Michael Jackson died I heard it on Twitter. When that Captain Cheeseburger guy landed his plane on the Hudson I heard it on Twitter and when Rhonda down the road found out her husband enjoyed being humped by his own dog, I heard it from my wife.
It’s a human trait to want to be the first with news and it’s the reason why so many conversations start with “Did you hear about…” And why you will often see a smile spread across the face of the person delivering the earth-shattering story when they realize they are actually breaking gossip….er….I mean news.
I know there are bad things going on even as I type this post. Kids are being abused, wives beaten, homes burgled, identity’s stolen and wars fought. But here’s the deal, 99.999% is so far out of my circle of influence that the only opportunity it offers is an opportunity to feel miserable.
The flip side of course is the vast majority of kids and women aren’t being abused. Most houses aren’t being broken into and most people haven’t had their identity’s stolen. And of course most people live in a country that isn’t at war.
I regularly ask clients their reasons for keeping up on the news and they usually respond with something like:
“Well it pays to be informed”
“It’s important to know what’s happening in the world”
“I wouldn’t want to miss out on anything”
I am sure I have heard 101 different reasons, mostly permutations of the above, but do you know the one answer I have NEVER been given?
“I really enjoy keeping up with news, it’s great fun”
Honestly, nobody has ever told me they do it because they enjoy it, which leaves me to presume they feel it’s some sort of human obligation. Or maybe they just don’t want to be the one person at the water cooler that didn’t know Bosnia and Herzegovina had merged with the The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia to form the worlds longest country name?
As somebody that used to listen to news and sports up to 6 hours a day when I worked in sales, I am not ignorant to the fact that it’s easy to get sucked into it. After all, I was the go to guy in quizzes when they needed to know who was the latest Member of Parliament caught on Clapham Common with his trousers round his ankles.
I’m sure some people will think that I am shirking my global responsibility, but nothing could be further from the truth. I am useless to anybody if I’m hiding under my duvet or having a heart attack brought on by stress and that is what news causes a lot of people because:
The purpose of news is not to inform you. The purpose of news is to scare you.
When a local news program leads with:
“5 reasons your kids are in more danger than you think- listen later for the full story”
They aren’t looking to enlighten you, or help your parenting skills. They’re looking to scare you into upping their ratings. Ratings = $’s and that is the purpose of the news, to make money.
So you watch the news, get exposed to some really negative language, hear yourself muttering how unsafe the world is and then take yourself off to bed for a good nights sleep or off to work to interact with a load of other pissed off people.
Doesn’t make much sense does it?
When I have this conversation people will readily agree with me about local news (not sure who watches it to be honest because nobody I ever speaks to admits as such), but insist national or international news is more important.
I do understand the rationale that it’s difficult to effect positive change in the world if you don’t know what it is that needs changing because you’re shielding yourself from the ‘real world’. But even in those cases I refer back to this one undeniable fact:
People will tell you about the important stuff.
Last year central Florida was on hurricane alert. I was in my local supermarket and just happened to be buying some batteries. The women on checkout asked me if I was stocking up for the hurricane. “What hurricane?” I replied, as it slowly dawned on me why the place was so busy at 10.30am on a Monday morning. And before you think I got lucky, this was 2 days before it was due to hit and it never even got close to Orlando anyway.
Even if you live in your bat cave and never speak to anybody, it’s possible to search the news head lines in about 10 seconds online to see if there is some juicy nugget that you simply have to know. A word of warning though; those headlines are cunningly designed to get you to click through and read the whole story, don’t do it!
Do you know anybody that benefits from the news that doesn’t directly or indirectly work in it?
I don’t, but I know lots of people that are worse off from it. People that can’t sleep properly, that live in a constant state of fear and worry about all sorts of things including a stressful economy, the state of their car and kids floating around in hot air balloons.
I know there are a few here that don’t take notice of the news, but if you don’t fit into that group and don’t need it for your work, what stops you dropping it for a week and seeing what difference it makes in your life? Trust me, it will be there if you decide you can’t live without it and want to rejoin the fold.
Here’s another awesome blog about not following the news:
http://www.raptitude.com/2009/06/theres-nothing-small-about-the-world/
I’ll still scan headlines over the ‘net, but the news is nothing but marketing: the news is simply about what sells:
* Things everyone is already talking about
* Things people are afraid of at the moment
* Things that happen to famous people
* Things that give people a chance to really dislike someone
* Things that will affect people on a large scale
“But here’s the deal, 99.999% is so far out of my circle of influence that the only opportunity it offers is an opportunity to feel miserable.”
It’s not that simple. All the misery in the world is not outside your circle of influence. I don’t mean you should become an advocate for “making the world a better place”, but you should admit that you, too, are part of society which, as a whole, creates all this unfairness, brutality etc… You further choose not to do anything about it, because as a human being your number 1 interest is still yourself and you are mainly being nice to other people because it benefits yourself.. To sum it up: 90 % of the horrible stuff in the news is inside of your circle of influence but you don’t want to care.
It’s true, of course, that a newspaper is a business and the owner intends to make money with it. The main purpose should keeping tabs on a world that very much needs new sounds poking around.
Amen.
I do not watch the news (I am 38 and have never owned a tv). I have a special dislike for the majority of “news” that is reported… I refer to this as “dead baby news.” Why in the world to I need someone to tell me horrific details of depressing occurrences? I don’t. I admit that I sometimes pick up a copy of The Economist – mainly because once I found they used the word avuncular and defenestration in the same issue and it amused me greatly. Other than that I wrote a little program that searches for news that I might need such as new laws, happy news, and the like. It works well.
The only draw back is that I am completely out of the loop when it comes to most pop culture etc and my friends have fun with it.
@ Vlad – Don’t diss balloon boy or your family will be damned for all eternity and then a bit longer.
@ JBT – Yeh, yeh, yeh. Already heard it on Fox News, Twitter and in the gym locker room.
The editorial saying they didn’t think you’d make it in the New York Times was a bit worrying.
I was sick today. It’s certainly the Swine Flu. Someone alert the CDC and Coast Guard.
Heartily agreed.
I have watched the news about 2 or 3 times over the last 5 years. I was always surprised by the sheer negativity of it.
And yeah, the important stuff will reach you. (The unimportant stuff too. Like the balloon boy incident. That just got me laughing, since apparently half the US was freaking out about a boy NOT being in a balloon :) )
@ Christine – Agggh, I know what you mean. I don’t mean to be all self promotional, but check this post out!
https://adaringadventure.com/blog/wordpress/life-coaching/the-recession-is-over/
@ AWTS – You see I hear that all the time, but in what way does it ‘pay’, what does that even mean?
I was brilliantly well informed in my 20’s and 30’s and I cannot think of anyway I actually benefited from it, other than being brilliantly well informed in news.
Knowing the weather or traffic conditions is not really the same as following news in the way I am talking about it.
I think watching news isn’t all that bad. As Tracy said, “it pays to be informed”. I turn on my radio for the latest traffic news. I change to my music channel after getting the info I need.
I believe that everything should be done in moderation, from eating to working…. including watching news.
Great post, Tim, it really has made me stop and think.
Some time ago, I decided to stop reading newspapers and watching the news on TV, and went for a good two to three years without looking at either. However, I got dragged back into reading the news and watching TV documentaries when the financial crisis really hit last year. I found the whole thing so intriguing – and frightening! – and it was great at some level to be able to chat with other people about how awful things were. Reading your article and looking at your little newspaper-reading sheep cartoon makes me realise, however, that part of the function of news is to keep us feeling like part of the herd. Not a place I’m REALLY happy to be!
I’m much happier when I don’t pay any or much attention to what’s going on, and find that I then have much more creative energy for other things in life. Having said that, I find it difficult to escape the news, especially when I travel around London because there are free newspapers morning and evening either being thrust in your hand when you try to enter a tube station, or lying, daring you to read them on train seats. It helps when I have a book, or a notebook with me, and can use my commuting time productively.
Time, Tim, for me to put the news to one side again and concentrate on the more positive things in life. Thanks for the great prompt!
Warm wishes
Christine
Why isn’t that bloody image showing. WordPress absolutely hates me. It does honest.
BWAAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAAHA!
@ Doug – I know that’s not at all funny in terms of what happened, but I did laugh when I read that.
Fear inducing and also depressing and erodes our belief in humanity would also be my guess.
@ Johnny – What do you mean?
@ Joely – I keep meaning to go look what happened on QT last night and forgetting. I’m guessing it all went smoothly and Griffin was a good boy and sans white pointy hat?
I have never heard of Biscuitgate, got to check that one out!
Excellent points. I go through spells when I get interested and I keep up with specific current events. Then I enjoy it. Like I’ve enjoyed, recently, commenting on the Jan Moir thing and the BNP thing over here. And of course, Biscuitgate was about the funniest thing I’ve seen for a while.
Usually my reason for following the news (aside from being interested in something specific), is to do with writing and intellectual curiosity. During my degree, we were advised to read The Economist to keep up with the news, mostly because it focused on what was happening, rather than spinning a scare story. Keeping up on current events (rather than what was considered “news” was vital for passing the degree because we needed relevant, up to date case studies to use for our work.
Now I refer to anything that comes up as relevant to Amnar and my fiction, because some of the politics is worth considering. And that’s not all. It’s often useful for inspiration, although I usually prefer to refer to history for that.
Dammit, Tim, stop stealing my ideas!
Oh yeah. I live in a tornado area and would trade for hurricanes any day of the week. ;-)
All the best!
deb
Although it was one of your top 10 overhyped books, what you propose is pretty similar to the “Low Information Diet” described by Tim Ferriss in the 4HWW. He was coming at it more from a productivity angle, but the benefits you describe would be even more impactful.
I was going to defend my habit of reading a daily newspaper, but then they went and published today’s issue with a 200 pt font headline saying “CHILD KILLER ON THE LOOSE”. Now, we did have a terrible tragedy in the area this week, and the headline is technically true, but it’s definitely presented in the most dramatic, fear-inducing way possible.
Okay, okay, so I’m the ultimate NPR addict! The hosts and correspondents are my friends, their voices so familiar, first thing in the morning :) I get excited for Saturday for my favorite radio show, the NPR News Quiz ‘Wait, Wait, Don’t Tell Me,’ and I know all the answers! Then there’s Car Talk, This American Life, the list goes on…
(I hope the fact that I hate television and never ever watch it makes me seem a bit more balanced…)
BUT……I’m taking a week off, starting Monday, no NPR, none! I will let you know how it goes :)
Tim, thanks for your comical wisdom, it cheers me!
Lisa
@ Angela – Yeh, I’m scared just reading what you say about the guy!
@ Andrew – Damn that balloon boy!
@ Jeff – Glad to hear it ;-)
@Tim – maybe, but I’m right there with ya’.
All too true Tim! News is all about control and fear mongering… Everyone should turn their tellie off for a week and they’ll have a much ‘lighter/carefree’ week…
And nope, you’re never getting the 10 minutes of your life back that balloon boy stole…
I agree with you. The news only pushes fear. So now it’s rare that I watch it, and if I do it’s only for about 5 minutes. If you get the chance check out the movie “Bowling for Columbine.” Don’t let the title fool you. It mainly talks about the very thing you mentioned. We are delivered news to make us fearful.
Kirk (sp) Cameron is a born-again former child star who stops people in the streets of my neighborhood to inform them, on camera naturally, that they’re sinners who are going to hell. He has lately been in the news because he plans to distribute doctored up versions of Origin of the Species in universities next month on the 150th anniversary of its publication — special version annotated to present a balanced argument that Darwin was a racist, misogynistic liar who perpetrated a huge hoax (with the help of Adolph Hitler) on humanity, namely, the theory of evolution.
Would that be a great Halloween costume, or what?!? Super-scary.
@ Tracy – I think elections are a different matter to be fair although Prop 16 is disgusting. No way should ferret fanciers have to do that EVERY single day.
@ Jeff – Yeh, but if more and more people turn their back on the crap that the media throw out, they’ll have to change and ultimately we’ll all live in a Utopian existence.
I’m being naive again, aren’t I?
@ Angela – Who’s Kurt Cameron?
Well, this is a good time of year to watch the news ….. for Halloween costume ideas! I had kind of been thinking of going as a pig carrying a box of kleenex, but those will probably be ubiquitous, so I’m switching to going as a Zombie Kurt Cameron, with a bible under one arm and “Origin of the Species” under the other.
And I’ll be “Ardi” is a big costume this year!
I hardly watch the news, but I do occasionally listen or read. About 50% of the time though it’s purely for comedic value…
I once read a news report, in a respectable NY newspaper, that actually said a new type of drug “decreases your chances of death by up to 20%.” Gotta get me some of that! I’m pretty sure a proofreader got fired over that…
Most of the media is fear based, encouraging people to make decisions out of fear, and thus propagating even more fear. Tough cycle to break.
@ Green – Actually you have me there., I must admit I like election coverage and do enjoy it, so in that respect I was wrong
I think we can agree neither of us our heartless and spreading misery serves nobody.
@ Steve – I agree mate there is always an agenda. It’s impossible for people to report stuff without viewing it through their own filters.
10 years? Wow, now that’s something to aspire to ;-)
@ howardsend – Every so often I’ll pick up a UK newspaper on the way out of the Supermarket, but our main local paper the Orlando Sentinel doesn’t really cover overseas news anyway. I bump into bits and bobs on the BBC website and I have a buddy that can’t wait to tell me when some British celebrity dies.
@ Deb – Gonna disagree. Buying a generator is a cool move if you can afford one, but it has nothing to do with what I’m saying. We have been under hurricane watch about 5 times in the 4 years I have lived here. You can’t miss it!
A day out and the place goes black for starters and everybody and anybody wants to talk about it. It would be impossible to miss one.
Now having said that, tornados maybe another matter, but unless you have a shelter your screwed if you get a direct hit by ones of those things.
I do enjoy reading the news during elections. I don’t read it all because it gets really repetitive, but I do watch it and keep up with it during those times because I find it fun. But outside of election season I think it is pretty much how you describe- fires that killed 14 people I never knew or recalls on cheap plastic nightmares I wouldn’t have bought anyway. I know a lot of people could argue that even during the election season the news is mostly crap. But I think it’s exciting.
This is the quote I got the most out of from this article: “99.999% is so far out of my circle of influence that the only opportunity it offers is an opportunity to feel miserable.” I definitely agree with that. It doesn’t make me heartless that I don’t care about disasters big and small that I don’t have any connection to. If that’s all the news has to offer me, what’s the point?
Dude. Hurricanes are actually a good reason to check out the news. I once laughed at my dad because after 12 years living in Central Florida, he bought a generator. For hurricanes. I laughed. Like a lot.
A few years later, 3 hurricanes hit central Florida in one year and they were without power for a couple of weeks each time. Dad laughed. Like a lot. (ha) Hurricanes (having food you can cook without the use of power, for example) are a good reason to listen to the news. ;-)
OK. I do think it’s important to know what is going on in the world, and will confess to being a political junkie. But too much of the 24-hour news channels isn’t about news. Most 24-hour channels are just ‘opinion shows’ based on personality.
And they follow balloon boy and scare us for a reason. Because if they don’t, everyone will flip over to the channel that does do that. They do it precisely because it works and that is what people watch. People like drama. If we asked for better by watching something else, we’d get better stuff.
But if you watch the news and get freaked out by it? Well then there are bigger problems than just watching news. ;-)
All the best!
deb
Hi Tim, thanks for the mention, I was very glad to do it.
You know why I don’t watch much news? There’s not much on there that I’d want my children to see. I don’t want them growing up to think that danger lurks on every corner and that they should trust nobody. I remember reading The Gift of Fear (or maybe it was Protecting the Gift) and there was a section that pointed out instead of teaching children never talk to strangers, full stop we need to let them know that there are people who can help them if they are lost and in trouble and how to use their good judgment and instincts to decide who to ask. How would they do that if they think everyone is about to murder them and send them off to the Middle East to be sex slaves and put the pictures on the internet?
On the flip side, I do think there are many situations where it pays to be informed. It’s pretty disheartening than going to the polls and realizing you have no idea what item 16 on the ballot is and no idea if you are for it or against it! This has happened to me, and I’m sure I’m not the only one. So, I try to get my news online where I feel I have more control over what I read.
On a related note, I wonder about the people who are all up in arms about things like Jon and Kate and outraged over the exploitation of the couple’s children but don’t miss an episode. If the children are being exploited, why take part in it by watching?
I do find it helpful to read int’l news headlines, as it helps me know where to look for a job next. Other news I follow if it interests me – which rarely includes balloons, hurricanes or swine flu. All this does make my world knowledge quite lop-sided, but I’m happy with that.
Brilliant!! Brilliant!! Brilliant!!
People think I’m weird when I tell them I haven’t read a newspaper or watched the news in over 10 years and I haven’t gone a funny shape because of it.
The news is out and out propaganda on every level and I am talking about the BBC as well. There is always an agenda to a news story and it scares the shit out of half the country, especially with this swine flu, it’s crazy.
Thanks for a great post Tim, as usual.
Still reading the book as well, when I get a bit time here and there. Thanks.