You may not know why they said it

A narrow path between brick walls and ivy.

Based on Tim Brownson’s original work

Written by Andy Hood, drawing on an original article by Tim Brownson, who founded A Daring Adventure.

A comment appears beneath something you have written. It sounds pointed. Before long, you have supplied a motive, written a response and mentally rehearsed the exchange in which the other person finally admits that you are right.

All this may happen before you have established what they meant.

Tim's original article reflected on responding defensively to an online challenge. Alongside that account, he explored how easily we form opinions and then protect them from contrary evidence. The useful connection is not that criticism should always be ignored. It is that we can become very certain about a stranger's motives with very little to go on.

Separate three questions

What did they actually say? What do you think they meant? What, if anything, requires a response?

These questions can lead to different answers. The comment might contain a factual error that is worth correcting even though you cannot know the motive behind it. It might identify a genuine problem in an unpleasant tone. It might be a preference you don't share, or an attempt to provoke an argument with no useful destination.

You don't have to settle the person's character before deciding what to do. In many cases you won't have enough information to settle it at all.

That uncertainty works both ways. Avoid assuming the critic is malicious, but don't insist on a benign explanation where the behaviour is threatening or abusive. You can set boundaries based on what is happening without diagnosing the person responsible.

Decide what a reply is for

A useful reply might correct the record, acknowledge a mistake, explain a decision or invite a specific clarification. Each has a possible endpoint.

A reply whose purpose is “make them understand that I am a good person” has rather less reliable stopping conditions. It can turn one exchange into an afternoon's unpaid appointment as curator of somebody else's opinion.

Before responding, ask who needs the information. If other readers could be misled, a concise public clarification may be worthwhile. If the issue concerns a private matter, keep private information out of the public exchange. If there is nothing useful to add, you can leave the comment unanswered.

Where the matter has legal, safeguarding or professional consequences, follow the appropriate process rather than improvising a debate. Preserve relevant evidence and get advice where needed. Ignoring everything is not a universal strategy.

Leave room to be corrected yourself

Suppose the comment points out something you genuinely got wrong. Your first interpretation may have been that the person was attacking you. New information may show that, however awkwardly expressed, the criticism was accurate.

You can update the work and say what changed. That isn't surrendering your judgement. It is using it.

The same habit applies away from the screen. If you think a colleague is unreliable, do you notice the occasions when they follow through? If you believe you always handle disagreement badly, do you count the times you listened and responded well? A view that ignores every exception may have become a rule you are enforcing rather than an observation you are testing.

Try naming what would change your mind. If the answer is “nothing”, ask whether you are dealing with a firm value, a well-supported conclusion or an opinion you have become reluctant to revisit. Those deserve different treatment.

You won't avoid every misunderstanding. You can reduce the number that grow because you defend an interpretation as though it were a fact. Pause long enough to establish what you know, choose a purpose for your response and let new evidence remain capable of changing the story.

If you found this article helpful, you might also enjoy Better Questions.

Andy Hood smiling in a checked shirt

The Adventure Edit

Join The Adventure Edit, my newsletter for ideas about making more deliberate choices. As a welcome, I’ll send you Does the life you’ve built still fit?, a free PDF workbook to help you notice what’s worth keeping and what you might try next.

Confirm your email to receive the workbook, then two follow-ups about using it and coaching. After that, occasional newsletters and coaching updates. Unsubscribe any time and keep the workbook. How I use your information.

ADA | The Adventure Edit and workbook | Consent v2026-11-15