Based on Tim Brownson’s original work
Written by Andy Hood, drawing on an original article by Tim Brownson, who founded A Daring Adventure.
“Why am I so useless?” looks like a question. In practice it has already delivered its verdict and is now inviting supporting evidence.
You can spend a long time answering it without learning anything useful about the situation that prompted it.
Tim's original article argued for better questions, including questions we ask ourselves and feedback we invite from other people. The important distinction wasn't simply positive versus negative. It was whether the question opened a route towards understanding or kept the same accusation circulating.
First, remove the verdict
Suppose you miss a deadline. “Why do I always ruin everything?” makes a claim about your character and your entire history. “What happened between agreeing this deadline and missing it?” asks about an event.
The second may uncover an uncomfortable answer. You may have accepted work you didn't have capacity for, delayed asking for help or underestimated the task. A useful question doesn't guarantee a flattering response. It makes the response specific enough to act on.
You can then ask: what needs repairing now, and what would reduce the chance of this happening again? That might involve an apology, a changed commitment or a clearer process. It doesn't require a general finding that you are either brilliant or hopeless.
Ask others without disguising an accusation
“What were you thinking?” can be a genuine request. Tone and context can also turn it into a formal announcement that the thinking was inadequate.
If a colleague arrives late, start with what you need to understand. “We couldn't begin the handover until you arrived. What happened, and how can we make the next one work?” names the effect without assuming the cause.
You may discover an avoidable mistake, an unclear agreement or a constraint nobody had considered. You can still set expectations and address repeated problems. Curiosity doesn't require abandoning standards.
Avoid questions that contain only one acceptable answer. “Don't you think you should have checked?” is usually a statement wearing a question mark. If your point is that checking was necessary, say so, then make room to discuss what prevented it.
Request feedback someone can actually give
“Any feedback?” often produces “It was good.” That may be sincere, but it gives you little to work with.
Ask about a specific part of the work. Was the purpose clear in the introduction? Which instruction was hardest to follow? What information did you need before making the decision? A person can answer these without producing a comprehensive assessment of you.
Choose someone with relevant experience and explain what sort of feedback would help. If you only want encouragement today, you can say that too. There is no benefit in inviting a detailed critique and then resenting someone for providing it.
When you receive feedback, check your understanding before defending the work. Ask for an example if the comment is vague. You don't have to agree with everything, but you do need to know what is being said before deciding whether to use it.
Feedback is evidence, not a command
Different readers or colleagues may want different things. One person's response may reveal a genuine problem, a preference or a misunderstanding that your explanation helped create.
Compare it with the purpose of the work and other evidence. If several people struggle at the same point, investigate. If a suggestion would undermine the goal, you can decline it while still appreciating the observation behind it.
Abuse is not made valuable by calling it honesty. You can seek useful criticism without accepting personal attacks or making yourself available to endless judgement.
For your next conversation, choose one question you have been asking repeatedly. Remove any accusation hidden inside it and make it specific enough that the answer could surprise you.
A good question doesn't have to sound profound. It needs to help you notice something you haven't already decided.
If you found this article helpful, you might also enjoy Better Questions.


